After a bad breakup, Maggie wants to find her Prince Charming. When her best friends, Savvy and Joan, demand she find a date worthy of attending their respective weddings, she agrees to try online dating. She's close to giving up when she meets a handsome doctor who just might be the one. Meanwhile, her college bestie, Garrett, throws salt in everyone's game. At every turn, he points out the red flags and tells Maggie to keep looking. When Maggie demands that Garrett be happy for her, he finally admits that he can't. When he blurts out his feelings, Maggie must choose between the perfect guy and a friendship that is the foundation for everything she's ever wanted.