Christmas is Emmie's first love. This year, Emmie creates a holiday-themed scavenger hunt that will bring her new boyfriend, Grant, to the town of Christmas Point where she's planned a romantic weekend. But a mix-up has the wrong guy following her clues! Sam, a best-selling mystery writer, thinks Emmie's clever Christmas riddles are from his agent. When he arrives at Christmas Point and finds the stunned Emmie, he immediately feels she's someone special. When Grant finally shows up, Emmie is disappointed to find he's not enjoying the activities she planned. With Christmas coming fast, Emmie will need the magic of the season to help steer her in the direction of true love.