On Ichabod Island, ten-year-old Sky becomes an orphan for the second time after an accident claims the lives of her adoptive parents. Grieving the death of his best friends, Leo's life is turned upside down when he finds himself Sky's guardian. Struggling to balance his new responsibilities and his marriage to his husband, Leo is supported by a community of neighbors. Maggie helps with Sky's childcare. Her best friend Agnes invites Sky's estranged grandmother to stay for the summer. Their neighbor Joe struggles with whether to tell all was not well in Sky's house leading up to the accident. Among them all is a mysterious woman, drawn to Ichabod to fulfill a dying wish.