The fishing village of Menemsha is a side of Martha's Vineyard tourists don't always see. Maddie Clarke hazily recalls childhood visits to her Grandma Nancy's cottage above Menemsha Harbor. It turns out Grandma Nancy didn't die long ago, as Maddie believed. In fact, Nancy just passed away at 89 - and left Maddie her cottage. Maddie intends her visit to be a brief one, but on arriving in Menemsha, she finds far more than memories. There are other family secrets waiting to be uncovered, and a Native American heritage Maddie knew nothing about. Most surprising of all, there is a chance to connect with her people and find herself, and perhaps find love, on this island.